Driverless cars may make the future of auto accident lawyers very difficult | Gregory S. Young Co., LPA
Call 24/7 for a FREE Consultation
Servicios En EspaƱol
Dayton: 937-531-7999 | Kentucky: 859-547-3334 | Toll Free: 888-783-1077
View Our Practice Areas

Driverless cars may make the future of auto accident lawyers very difficult

Self-driving cars: The next big hurdle in auto accident law.

Google-Driverless-Taxi-Cab-537x389.jpgWith news reporting that Self-Driving cars would be road-ready by 2020, it seems like the future is easily here. What has once science fiction and the imaginings of Batman writers is becoming a reality. Besides saving the government money and increasing road safety, the effects of a society that includes driverless vehicles are really hard to imagine.

In the world of personal injury, of course, that is a problem. The State of Ohio reported a staggering 287,050 crashes in 2012, with almost 75,000 of them including some form of injury.

But all of that might change with algorithm-driven vehicles. Google reported that its main test car has gone 300,000 miles without a single accident. Of all of the autonomous cars on the road today, they've only had three accidents total; and each one the driverless car was not at fault.

So what happens when a driverless car is at fault?


"Negligence is usually defined as with the reasonably prudent person standard," says Ahmed Hassan, a personal injury in Cincinnati, OH, "I don't think that a car or artificial intelligence can be sued for negligence. By definition they would be incapable of being negligent."

Not that people haven't tried. In 2010 a Paris Court ordered a judgment against not only Google, but its search engine, ordering the google's AI to make a symbolic 1-Euro payment after suggesting defamatory words as part of a search for the plaintiff's name. Google, meanwhile, had to pay almost 5000 euros in the judgment.

This begs the question: if you're not to sue the AI, then who? "whoever set the car's controls would be responsible," says litigation attorney Tod Mollaun. "If that is the manufacturer, then it is a product defect." But if those controls were set by a driver, then they may have to take responsibility for the car whether they are the personally operating the vehicle themselves, much like if a child were to be injured by a moving santa-on-a-train display in your yerd, you would still be liable.

car-driverless.jpgIt may even be more complicated. Forbes reports that automakers plan to use the same radio spectrum currently used for Wi-Fi. This, some speculate, might lead to a disruption of communication between the car and satelites-leading to a fatal car accident-just because someone really needed to download another cat picture to their laptop nearby.

Ultimately, however, it's simply hard to imagine what the future of automated cars will actually be like, and it will be entirely new territory when a case reaches the courts. "Trying to predict how existing case law would apply to the situation would depend largely on the state in which it occurred and the specific facts of the accident," says attorney Andrew Trice. "For example, the fact that the driver ignored a rule or disrupted the auto-pilot somehow would be very significant."

Speculations about the court's decisions are about as reliable as speculations about insurance premium drops once automated cars are on the road. Until then, we can only dream of a future where we can nap on our way to work. And if we encounter one of Google's driverless cars on a San Francisco road...well, we'll just give it a wide berth.

For more interesting legal news, please follow on Twitter @GregoryYoungLaw

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Meet Our Attorneys

Meet Our Attorneys

At Gregory S. Young Co., LPA, our lawyers have one goal: to help you rebuild your life after an accident. We are committed to getting you and your family the resources your need to treat your injuries, pay your bills and move forward to a brighter future.

Meet Our Attorneys
Gregory S. Young Craig Michael Belliston Christopher D. Byers Michelle L. Mendelsberg Teran T. Tod Mollaun J. Clark Norris Douglas Kilgore Dalton Brian M. Cable Alexis Toledo Andrew Trice Michele L. Young
  • avvo top contributor 2015 car accident
  • Gregory S. Young Co., LPA BBB Business Review
Email Us For A Response

Start Your Claim Now.
Set Up A Free Consultation

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Office Locations

Gregory S. Young Co., LPA
600 Vine Street, Suite 402
Cincinnati, OH 45202

Toll Free: 888-783-1077
Phone: 937-531-7999
Phone: 859-547-3334
Phone: 513-721-1077
Fax: 513-721-1919
Cincinnati Law Office Map

Toll Free: 888-783-1077
Cincinnati: 513-721-1077
Dayton: 937-531-7999
Kentucky: 859-547-3334
Fax: 513-721-1919
  • Finneytown office
    8970 Winton Road
    Cincinnati, OH 45231
    Phone: 513-766-5936
    Map and Directions

  • Western Hills office
    4997 Glenway Avenue
    Cincinnati, OH 45238
    Phone: 513-766-5937
    Map and Directions

  • Mason office
    7577 Central Parke Boulevard
    Mason, OH 45040
    Phone: 513-766-5938
    Map and Directions

  • West Chester office
    8050 Beckett Center Drive
    West Chester, OH 45069
    Phone: 513-766-5939
    Map and Directions

  • Northgate office
    9600 Colerain Avenue, Suite 205
    Cincinnati, OH 45251
    Phone: 513-766-5940
    Map and Directions

  • Clermont County office
    4030 Mount Carmel-Tobasco Road, Suite 123
    Cincinnati, OH 45255
    Toll Free: 513-766-5942
    Map and Directions

  • Blue Ash/Kenwood office
    9403 Kenwood Road, Suite D-108
    Cincinnati, OH 45242
    Phone: 513-766-5941
    Map and Directions

  • Florence office
    71 Cavalier Boulevard, Suite 121
    Florence, KY 41042
    Phone: 859-547-3334
    Map and Directions

  • Tri-County office
    230 Northland Boulevard, Suite 203
    Cincinnati, OH 45246
    Phone: 513-721-8855
    Map and Directions

  • Columbus Office
    4449 Easton Way
    Suite 200
    Columbus, OH 43219
    Phone: 614-232-6301
    Map and Directions

  • Dayton Office
    70 Birch Alley
    Suite 240, Building B
    Beavercreek, OH 45440
    Phone: 937-531-7999
    Map and Directions

  • Toledo Office
    1715 Indian Wood Circle
    Maumee, OH 43537
    Phone: 567-316-6215
    Map and Directions